Anthony’s Italian Deli Coming Soon to Barrington, NJ. Hometown Family

Anthony’s Italian Deli is coming to Barrington, where resident Brittany Cristinzio and her son Anthony are working to bring fresh sandwiches, prepared foods, imported favorites and a little taste of Italy to their hometown.

The deli is taking over a familiar corner storefront at Trenton Avenue and Gloucester Pike, about one block off Clements Bridge Road. It’s basically across the street from the new Dollar Tree and the former St. Francis de Sales Church.

It’s another nice win for Barrington which at this intersection area recently saw the opening of Dollar Tree in the former Rite Aid, and new new Royal Greens mini-golf was just approved!

For the upcoming deli, I mostly remember the corner store space as a small Mister Softee ice cream shop. But for many longtime Barrington residents, the building brings back memories of Sally’s Deli… particularly its selection of penny candy!

And from the memories being shared about the property, I recently learned that even before Sally’s, the location was known as Purnell’s, going back to the early 1960s.

Now Brittany and Anthony are working toward giving the neighborhood storefront its next chapter.

I recently caught up with Brittany, who is also a successful local real estate agent. Back in July, she announced the deli plans on her personal Facebook page, and she has been sharing progress updates as short “stories” through her other social media channels.

In that summertime announcement, Brittany said she couldn’t wait to bring fresh sandwiches, prepared foods, imported favorites and a little taste of Italy to Barrington.

I stopped by over the weekend to check on the progress. Over the last few months, Brittany and Anthony have been working through the approvals and infrastructure improvements needed to get the space ready for the new deli.

A main focus of the initial work has been plumbing, which they expect to have completed within the next week. From there, their contractor is ready to move into the interior buildout.

It’s not an overly large space so she doesn’t expect the core interior buildout to take too long. An opening date has not been locked in, but they are hoping to welcome their first customers before the new year.

That would potentially put Anthony’s opening during at least part of the holiday season. I’m sure Brittany and Anthony would love to have the doors open in time to become part of the community’s holiday food shopping, although the timing is still a goal.

For now, the broader concept centers on sandwiches, prepared foods and imported Italian favorites. A dedicated online presence for Anthony’s has not yet been launched, so we’ll save more of the menu and specialty-product details for Brittany and Anthony to share as things move forward.

Hometown Brittany and her son Anthony are opening Anthony’s Italian Deli in Barrington! (Instagram tour from July)

But Brittany has already invited the community to help shape what they’ll find inside.

Her July announcement asked residents which menu items were must-haves for an Italian deli, along with any specialty products they would like the new business to carry.

The response was impressive: about 130 comments!

Suggestions included chicken cutlets, paninis, Grana Padano and other imported cheeses. Several commenters also asked about gluten-free options.

Those were community requests rather than an announced menu, but the response clearly shows the interest in having an Italian deli at this location.

Alongside the food suggestions were memories from longtime residents who remembered stopping into Sally’s Deli. It’s nice to see that neighborhood history being shared as Brittany and Anthony work toward opening a new deli in the same corner-store location… and creating new community memories

Links And Location

Anthony’s Italian Deli – Coming Soon
25A W Gloucester Pike
Barrington NJ

Social Media – Coming Soon

Leave a Comment