Pizzeria Cusumano Announces Expected October Collingswood Opening

Pizzeria Cusumano, an all-new pizza shop coming to Haddon Avenue in Collingswood, has announced that it expects to open in October 2026 after several years of development.

Located just steps from the Collingswood PATCO station, the new pizzeria is being developed by Sal Cusumano, a member of the well-known South Jersey pizza family behind Angelo’s Pizza in West Berlin, Riverside and Voorhees.

I first learned about the Collingswood plans five years ago, when Michael Klein of The Philadelphia Inquirer highlighted the proposed pizzeria and some of the ideas Sal was working to bring to the new business.

In 2024, I covered the opening of My Angelo’s relocated West Berlin restaurant, where the family moved into a significantly larger and completely remodeled space on Route 73. That project was likely a valuable learning experience as the younger Cusumano and his father worked toward opening a pizzeria in Collingswood.

Angelo's West Berlin, NJ is Open
Angelo’s West Berlin, NJ is Open. Family members are now opening Pizzeria Cusumano in Collingswood.

The first Instagram post for the upcoming new pizzeria was on September 16th, 2021!

It is unclear why the Collingswood development process has taken as long as it has. The exterior of the completed-looking building has appeared on Google Street View since at least May of this year, and as mentioned was first announced in 2021.

But the most important news is that Pizzeria Cusumano finally appears ready to open its doors.

The restaurant shared a teaser video on Instagram yesterday, beginning with a view of the location beside the PATCO station. The camera then moves through the front door, offering a beautiful panoramic look at the customer area before showing Sal putting on his chef’s jacket and firing up the ovens.

The video closes with the announcement: “Pizzeria Cusumano — Coming October 2026.”

From the Pizzeria Cusumano Instagram Teaser Reel.

While an exact grand-opening date has not been announced, comments from people who live and work nearby suggest that the ovens are already being put to good use. Several commenters mentioned regularly smelling the delicious aroma of pizza coming from the shop.

Klein’s earlier coverage explained that Sal had been working with a restaurant consultant to develop a specialized dough that would be lighter and less filling. The goal was to create something different from the thin-crust, New York-style pizza traditionally served by the family’s My Angelo’s restaurants.

The Instagram preview also offers a quick glimpse of a neon sign mounted inside the restaurant that reads, “Welcome Home Pizza Lovers.”

After years of planning, construction and recipe development, that message seems to perfectly capture what Sal and the Cusumano family have been working to create in Collingswood: a new home for pizza lovers.

Links and Location

Pizzeria Cusumano – Opening October 2026
872 A Haddon Ave
Collingswood NJ

Instagram